When looking for a good hike in Sedona, I was overwhelmed with choices, and I think that not many of them are bad. So, I looked for one that was about 5 miles with not too much elevation gain. I chose Soldier's Pass because it fit that criteria as well as touting a large sinkhole (the Devil's Kitchen), some arches, and seven sacred pools.
We found the sinkhole and pools (the pools are nowhere as impressive as the seven sacred pools on Maui, but they are still nice to see on the hike), but the guide said that the side hike to the arches was via an unmarked trail on the right, and we passed a number of such possibilities that we didn't want to try them, just in case the arches were not at the end of them. So, no arches. But we did see lots and lots of beautiful scenery, including red rocks galore.
We also ran into some Carleton alums along the way. They noticed my shirt and started a conversation which gave us not only a pleasant interaction, but a nice 20-minute rest. They live in northern Minnesota but spend every March in Sedona and April in Palm Springs.
This is the Devil's Kitchen.
One of the sacred pools (or puddles).
Not exactly arches, but some caves in the distance that were pretty enough to photograph.
From near the top of Soldier's Pass, this is our view with Sedona in the background. We had about an 800 ft. elevation gain.
This is a rock formation that I particularly liked. It looked like a group of people.